Heat Pump Comparison

(We may earn a commission if you buy a product through one of our links, at no cost to you.)

Check out the heat pump comparison guide of the best models for 2016 and 2017 and save time and money when selecting the best product for heating and cooling your home. We will compare air to air heat pumps coming from the most popular manufacturers in US and Canada such as Lennox, Trane, Carrier, Armstrong, Rheem and other.

HVAC problems? Get Free Quotes Today!

Heat pumps comparison - based on efficiency

The selected models are top of the line models that have the most advanced features, longest warranty, highest efficiency, but higher price. Let’s compare the features, check out the ratings from other sources and user reviews.

Model SEER HSPF WarrantyCompressor Noise level
Lennox XP25 23.5 10.2 10/10 58
Amana AVZC20 21 10 L. Lifetime/10 57
Trane XV20i 20 10 12/10 57-75
Armstrong 4SHP20LX 20 10 10 67
Carrier 25VNAO 20.5 13 10 58

Lennox XP25 is coming from the Dave Lennox Signature collection and based on over 100 user reviews it is highly rated – 4.7. Lennox XP25 heat pump can be combined with the solar heating systems and with its dual-fuel capability can bring more flexibility and savings. Precise Comfort feature uses the inverter control compressor and its variable speed, to allow better temperature control for higher efficiency no matter the climate.

Amana AVZC20 model utilize the high efficiency variable speed compressor (swing type) and ECM condenser fan motor for greater performance, advanced diagnostics for better operation control and troubleshooting and improved design for the reduced sound level.

The main feature found on Trane XVi20 include the TruComfort system and its variable speed compressor and fan to ensure the proper operating speed and power, as much as needed to maintain the performance and comfort and to avoid frequent changes in the temperature.

Armstrong 4SHP20LX comes with the variable speed fan, factory installed crankcase and special fan blade design for quiet operation. It utilizes the inverter driven scroll compressor to adjust its work based on the needs, save on energy and provide an accurate temperature. All the components are packed inside the strong casing.

Carrier 25VNAO is coming from Infinity 20 category that has one of the highest EER and HSPF ratings in the industry. As the above models, Carrier 25VNAO also comes with the variable speed compressor but it includes the Greenspeed intelligence that combines an adaptable-speed technology and Infinity control’s intelligence and enhanced humidity control for extra comfort and lower energy usage.

In addition to the above list, we will present you a few comparisons done by HVAC and heat pump experts.

Heat pumps comparison - user reviews and prices

Furnacecompare.com provides a heat pump comparison guide based on the user satisfaction review:

  • Coleman LX (4.4 out of 5)
  • Goodman DSZC18 (3.9 out of 5)
  • Trane XR15 (3.4 out of 5)
  • York LX (3.1 out of 5)
  • Carrier Infinity (2.9 out of 5)
  • Lennox XP16 (2.8 out of 5)
  • Amana ASZ16 (2.7 out of 5)

Webhvac.com offers an article with their list of the best heat pumps for 2016. Check out the top five models with the prices:

  • American Standard AccuComfort Platinum 20 – Price $4,000-$5,200
  • Carrier Infinity 20 Greenspeed – Price $3,900-$4,800
  • Maytag PSH4BG iQ Drive – Price $3,500-$4,400
  • Heil QuietComfort HCH6 – Price $3,200-$4,200
  • Rheem Classic RP17 – Price $3,000-$4,100

Heatpumpguide.com has compiled the list according to the user satisfactions. Here is the list of top 5:

  • Lennox
  • Amana
  • Rheem
  • Trane
  • Bryant

Heatpumppricingguides.com compares heat pumps prices for 3-ton systems. The prices are for the complete installed system and round up to the nearest hundred.

  • Amana $5,400
  • American Standard $7,800
  • Armstrong $4,600
  • Carrier $8,000
  • Coleman $5,300
  • Goodman $4,600
  • Lennox $6,700
  • Rheem $5,000
  • Trane $8,600
  • York $4,700

The heat pump comparison guide is a list of the best and most popular models for the year 2016/2017, based on our research and other experts. The chosen models are high performing models that use the latest technology in HVAC heat pump industry while reducing the energy bills and making your home comfortable for years to come. If choosing the heat pump solely for its efficiency, Lennox and Carrier are the one to choose.

Heating Problems? Contact an Expert Today!